Are you looking for reliable online handmade marketplaces aside from Etsy? Amazon’s new marketplace might hold your interest.

Amazon Handmade Marketplace – What You Need To KnowOver the past few days, Etsy “makers,” the independent artisans that sell handmade items from jewelry to handmade soaps, have been receiving emails from Amazon, surveying their interest in a new platform that the e-commerce behemoth is preparing to launch called Amazon Handmade.

Etsy has carved out a cozy corner of cyberspace where the makers of handcrafted items and sellers of vintage items gather to reach an audience. Etsy has been able to stand out successfully in the otherwise cutthroat climate of e-tail. There were 1.4 million active sellers on Etsy last year, and their goods were snapped up by 19.8 million active buyers.

Etsy vs. Amazon – Rates

Etsy currently offers very competitive rates to handmade sellers trying to grow their own cottage industries. Etsy charges just 20 cents to list an item on its site for four months. It then charges just 3.5 percent of the subsequent sale.

Amazon offers vendors big and small access to its growing audience. Amazon doesn’t charge any listing fees for individuals looking to sell no more than 40 items a month through the site, but it does charge them 99 cents for each sale, and then we get into variable costs that typically consume another 6 percent to 15 percent of the ultimate sale, depending on the product category.

Amazon Handmade could have its hands full if it prices itself out of Etsy’s vendor base, but there’s also something to be said about the new platform providing incremental sales. If the fees are fair, there’s no reason a talented artisan can’t sell through both digital storefronts. Amazon would expand a craftsman’s client base, and there isn’t anything wrong with that.

Now we have the Amazon challenge, which at the very least will draw attention away from Etsy as the marketplace of choice for handmade goods. If Amazon promotes Amazon Handmade with the same kind of home-page marketing push that it has used to promote Kindle products in the past, it’s going to draw a crowd. That’s great news for potential sellers on the new site, but it may not be such good news for Etsy itself.

Advantages Of Amazon Over Etsy

Amazon has a few distinct advantages upon entering this arena, first among them being an enormous shipping network that is already in place worldwide. Also, the number of Etsy’s active buyers, a growing 20.8 million, seems unsubstantial in comparison to Amazon’s 278 million active accounts. Amazon’s large customer base could be very appealing to many Etsy sellers hoping to gain more online traction. In case that wasn’t enough to scare Etsy, they may be in some financial trouble after going public, seeing Etsy’s stock shares crashed by 50% in less than 2 months, and reporting a $36.6 million loss in the first quarter of the year.

However, Etsy has one point in its corner. The Brooklyn-based company charges its sellers a paltry 3.5% commission, pennies in comparison to Amazon’s 15% cut.

Will Amazon’s presence in this niche be a threat to Etsy? Will it expand consumer appetite for handmade products? We still don’t have all of the answers, but you can check it out if it suits your business goals in this space in the coming months.

So for now, do you think you’ll be comfortable in selling in this new platform? What are your thoughts about it? Please let us know in the comment box below.

Gary Capps

I live in the one of the most beautiful places in the world on the Sunshine Coast in Australia with my wife and our 2 dogs, Poppy and Mia. Since 2009 I have helped over 15,000 handmade business owners to grow their business with our software and free tools designed for todays entrepreneurial artisan.

Related Posts

Tags: , , , , , , ,

4 Responses to “Amazon Handmade Marketplace – What You Need To Know”

  1. Brandy 01. Jul, 2015 at 1:05 pm #

    There is a new online marketplace that sales American made handcrafted items only.

  2. Beth 01. Jul, 2015 at 12:28 am #

    I think it’s a great opportunity. But it’s definitely geared towards full time businesses. The commission and fees are not too high if you think of the costs of gallery commissions or memberships, booth fees, etc. Plus, with a more limited/juried marketplace, there is potentially a higher chance of sales as handcrafts are not drowned out by junk. I hope.

  3. Tari 29. Jun, 2015 at 11:46 pm #

    I think the 12% I saw is a hefty fee plus the fixed amount per sale once it sells. Then once August of 2016 comes, sellers will have to pay $40 a month to be allowed to continue. I know I myself can’t afford anything that charges so much. Even though I applied, if I get accepted I don’t know if I’ll be listing in there or not. I’ll feel like I need to really jack up my prices which doesn’t seem fair to people buying the same thing from me on Etsy, my website or craft fairs. jmho

    • Maria Rodrigues 30. Jun, 2015 at 4:15 pm #

      I agree. 3.5% is still OK but 15% is a little too high for me. I would like to check other options than etsy, though.
      And paying $40 / month? That’s not an option for me yet.

Leave a Reply